Raising Stoics
Study brief · Anger and tantrums

Emotion coaching: helping with feelings, not just stopping them

The short version: Emotion coaching — how parents respond to a child's feelings — matters. Children whose parents name and talk through emotions tend to regulate themselves better, and a short parenting course that teaches this reduced behavior problems in a randomized trial.

Help your child handle big feelings. A 12-week program for kids 5–6: 20 minutes, twice a week.
See the program

The studies

Gottman, J. M., Katz, L. F., & Hooven, C. (1996). Parental meta-emotion philosophy and the emotional life of families: Theoretical models and preliminary data. Journal of Family Psychology, 10(3), 243–268. doi:10.1037/0893-3200.10.3.243

Who was studied: 56 families with 4- to 5-year-olds, seen again three years later, when the children were about 8.

Design: Observational, longitudinal

What they found: Parents differed in how they treated their own and their children's emotions: some noticed feelings, named them, and helped the child work through them ("emotion coaching"); others dismissed or disapproved of them. At age 8, children of coaching parents scored better on measures of regulation, were rated by teachers as getting along better with peers, and did better on academic tests.

Havighurst, S. S., Wilson, K. R., Harley, A. E., Prior, M. R., & Kehoe, C. (2010). Tuning in to Kids: Improving emotion socialization practices in parents of preschool children — findings from a community trial. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 51(12), 1342–1350. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7610.2010.02303.x · free full text

Who was studied: 216 primary caregivers of children ages 4 to 5, randomly assigned to the course or a waitlist.

Design: Randomized controlled trial

What they found: After six group sessions plus two boosters, parents coached emotions more and dismissed them less, and were observed using more emotion words with their children. The children's understanding of emotions improved, and both parents and teachers reported fewer behavior problems.

How strong is the evidence?

Moderate. The idea comes from a small observational study, but it has since been tested in randomized trials like Tuning in to Kids, which is the stronger evidence. One caution: the program's developers ran the trial.

What these studies don't show

  • They don't show that coaching stops a tantrum in the moment. The benefits are about how children handle feelings over months, not about ending a meltdown faster.
  • Emotion coaching isn't permissiveness. Both studies define coaching as including limits on behavior; what changed was how the feeling was treated.

What it means for parents

  • Name the feeling before you fix the problem: "You're really disappointed." Then deal with what happens next.
  • Save the teaching for after the storm. During it, stay close and say little.
  • Use more feeling words in ordinary conversation — the trial measured exactly this, and it increased.

What is emotion coaching?

Emotion coaching is a way of responding to a child's feelings that treats them as a chance to connect and teach, rather than something to stop as quickly as possible. The term comes from psychologist John Gottman's research with families in the 1990s.

Gottman described it in five steps. Notice the child's emotion, ideally while it's still small. See it as an opportunity for closeness and teaching, not a nuisance. Listen with empathy and validate the feeling. Help the child put a name to it. And then, if needed, set limits on behavior and help the child figure out what to do.

The last step is often missed. Emotion coaching doesn't mean every behavior is acceptable. It means the feeling is accepted — "You're furious that we have to leave" — while the behavior can still be limited: "I won't let you kick. Let's find another way."

Gottman contrasted it with other common styles: dismissing feelings ("You're fine, stop crying"), disapproving of them ("Stop that right now or no park tomorrow"), and accepting feelings but setting no limits at all. In this study, children of emotion-coaching parents did better on measures of regulation, peer relations, and academic achievement.

Emotion coaching vs. dismissing: what it sounds like at home

The difference is often a single sentence.

A child's tower falls and they burst into tears. Dismissing: "It's just blocks, don't cry, build it again." Coaching: "Oh no, it fell — you worked so hard on that. That's really disappointing." Then, once the tears slow: "Want to try again, or take a break?"

A child is furious because a friend didn't share. Dismissing: "Don't be silly, you have plenty of toys." Coaching: "You really wanted the red truck, and he wouldn't give it to you. That made you angry." Then: "What could you say to him next time?"

A child is scared of the dark. Dismissing: "There's nothing to be scared of." Coaching: "The dark feels scary tonight. Lots of kids feel that. What would help you feel a bit braver?"

Notice that coaching doesn't solve the problem for the child or remove the limit. It names the feeling, shows that it makes sense, and only then moves to what to do. Dismissing tries to skip straight to the end, and it often leaves the child feeling unheard.

Emotion coaching during a tantrum

Emotion coaching looks a little different at the peak of a tantrum, because a child in the middle of a storm can't talk things through.

In the moment, the coaching is mostly presence. Stay close, keep everyone safe, and use very few words: "You're really upset. I'm here." Hold any limit calmly — "I won't let you throw" — without adding lectures. Naming the feeling in one short line can help; long explanations don't.

As the wave comes down, the coaching starts. A hug, a drink, and then a simple naming of what happened: "You were so angry when the tablet went off." The child's feeling is acknowledged, not argued with.

The problem-solving comes last, often much later — at bedtime or the next day. "When the tablet has to go off, what could help? A warning? Choosing the last video?" This is where children start to build their own strategies.

Done this way, emotion coaching doesn't make tantrums disappear overnight. But over months it may help. In the Tuning in to Kids trial, parents and teachers reported fewer behavior problems six months after the course; tantrum length and frequency were not measured.

Common emotion coaching mistakes

Emotion coaching is simple to describe and surprisingly easy to get slightly wrong. A few patterns come up again and again.

Coaching at the peak. Trying to talk through feelings while a child is screaming rarely works; at that point most children can't take in words. Save the conversation for when the wave has passed, and in the moment just stay close and name the feeling in one line.

Naming as a script. "I hear that you're feeling frustrated" said in a flat, rehearsed voice can sound like a technique rather than understanding, and children notice. Short, genuine, and specific works better: "You wanted the blue one. Ugh."

Validating the feeling, dropping the limit. Accepting that a child is angry doesn't mean letting them hit or giving them the thing they're angry about. Emotion coaching includes limits; in Gottman's description, limit-setting and problem-solving are the last step, not an optional extra.

Fixing too fast. Jumping from "you're sad" to three solutions in one breath skips the part where the child feels understood. Pause after naming the feeling. Sometimes that's all that's needed.

Only coaching the big feelings. Coaching works best when it's part of ordinary days — noticing small disappointments, frustrations, and excitements — so the child has practice before the big storms.

Expecting instant results. Gottman followed families for three years, and the Tuning in to Kids trial measured change six months after the course — not days. Emotion coaching is a habit that gradually changes how a child handles feelings, not a trick that stops a tantrum on the spot.

FAQ

How do I help my kids regulate their emotions?

Start by helping them notice and name feelings, on calm days as well as hard ones. In the moment, stay close and calm, say little, and keep everyone safe. Afterward, talk about what happened and plan what they could do next time. Teach one or two physical calming tools, like a slow breath out. Children also learn regulation from watching a calm adult.

Is emotion coaching the same as gentle parenting?

They overlap but aren't the same. Emotion coaching is a specific, research-based approach to responding to feelings, from John Gottman's work, and it includes setting limits on behavior. Gentle parenting is a broader, looser label used for many styles. Emotion coaching has been tested in randomized trials, which many gentle-parenting approaches draw on.

Does emotion coaching mean no limits?

No. Emotion coaching accepts the feeling, not every behavior. A coaching parent might say, "You're angry, and that's okay. I won't let you hit." Limits are part of the method; the difference is that they come alongside empathy rather than instead of it. In Gottman's research, setting limits on behavior is part of the definition of emotion coaching, not a separate add-on.

At what age can you start emotion coaching?

From the very beginning. With babies and toddlers it's mostly naming feelings and comforting. As language grows, many children can start linking feelings to their causes and choosing between simple options. With 4- to 7-year-olds, emotion coaching can become a real conversation, with problem-solving afterward. Parents use it with teenagers too — the words just get more grown-up.

What if emotion coaching doesn't seem to work for my child?

Check the timing first: coaching at the peak of a tantrum rarely works, so try it as the feeling fades or later. Keep it shorter and more genuine, and make sure limits are still clear. The Tuning in to Kids trial measured change six months after the course, so allow months rather than weeks. If big feelings are very frequent, intense, or getting worse despite this, talk to your pediatrician about extra support.

Does emotion coaching work for tantrums?

It helps, mostly over time rather than in the moment. During a tantrum, staying close, keeping everyone safe, and naming the feeling briefly is what emotion coaching looks like. The bigger effect comes from the conversations afterward and on calm days, which teach children words and strategies. In the Tuning in to Kids trial, parents and teachers reported fewer behavior problems six months after the course.

The Dragon Inside, the Pause Button, and Weather Inside (lessons 3–5) build exactly these habits: naming the feeling, pausing, then choosing.

See the program

Next article

5-Year-Old Tantrums: Temper Tantrums at 4–6 and What Helps

5-year-old tantrums and temper tantrums at home: how common they are at 4–6, why they happen, what to do before, during and after, and when to worry.

Read next →