What Is a Growth Mindset? Growth Mindset for Kids, Explained

What is a growth mindset, in plain terms?

It's the belief that ability is something you build rather than something you were handed. A child with a fixed mindset reads a failure as information about who they are. A child with a growth mindset reads the same failure as information about the method they used.

The practical difference shows up in one moment: what happens after something goes wrong. One child stops, because continuing risks more evidence that they aren't good at it. The other tries a different way, because the way is the only thing that was wrong.

What is a growth mindset vs. a fixed mindset in a 5-year-old?

You can see the difference in what a child does in the ten seconds after something goes wrong.

A child leaning toward a fixed mindset treats a failure as a verdict. The tower fell, so "I'm bad at building." The drawing looks wrong, so it gets scribbled over and the crayons go back in the box. Trying again feels risky, because another failure would confirm the verdict.

A child leaning toward a growth mindset treats the same failure as information. The tower fell, so "the bottom was too small." The drawing looks wrong, so they try the dog's legs a different way. The failure is about the method, and methods can change.

Most children are a mix, and it shifts by activity: a child can be relaxed about puzzles and rigid about drawing. It also shifts with mood. That's useful to know, because it means you're not trying to install a personality. You're trying to make "try it a different way" the more common response, one small moment at a time.

Why does praising a child for being smart backfire?

Because it tells them that their performance is a readout of a fixed quality. Once that's established, the safest thing to do is avoid anything hard, since a struggle would revise the verdict downward.

This has been measured many times, and the pattern has mostly held up: in those studies, children praised for ability afterward chose easier tasks, gave up sooner, and were more likely to misreport their scores. Children praised for what they did — the effort, the strategy, the persistence — choose harder tasks and recover faster.

It is not that "you're so smart" is cruel. It's that it is information about the wrong thing.

So what do I say instead?

Describe what they actually did, as specifically as you can.

"You kept going after it fell over." "You tried holding it a different way that time." "You went back to the part that wasn't working." These are all observations, and observations are checkable — which is why children believe them.

The test for any piece of praise: could they repeat the thing you named? "You're so smart" can't be repeated on purpose. "You tried it three different ways" can.

Does the word "yet" really do anything?

On its own, not much. Added to a sentence a child has just said in frustration, quite a lot.

"I can't do it" is a statement about them. "I can't do it yet" is a statement about where they are on a route. The word converts a verdict into a position, and many 5-year-olds hear that difference if you let them say both versions out loud and compare.

What it cannot do is work as a correction. If "yet" arrives as a cheerful contradiction while they're furious, it reads as being told they're wrong to be upset.

My child melts down when they fail. Is that a mindset problem?

Usually not, at ages 4 to 7. That's a regulation problem, and it comes first.

During a meltdown, the part of the brain that would process "you can improve with practice" is not available. Anything you say in that window is spent. Wait for it to pass — most storms at this age are over within a few minutes — and do the mindset work afterward, quietly, when they can hear it.

A useful sequence: first the feeling passes, then the word, then the retry. Reversing that order is one of the most common ways this goes wrong.

What's the most useful thing I can do as a parent?

Fail visibly, in front of them, and narrate it plainly.

Children calibrate what failure means by watching how the adults around them handle it. If every mistake you make is met with irritation or silence, they learn that mistakes are shameful regardless of what you say about effort.

"I've got this wrong. Let me try a different way" — said out loud, without drama, while doing something ordinary — often teaches more than any conversation about mindset.

How to develop a growth mindset in kids, day to day

Four habits do most of the work, and none of them requires a special program.

Describe the process, not the child. "You tried three ways before that one worked" instead of "you're so smart." It tells them what to repeat.

Name the hard part. When something is difficult, say so plainly: "This is the tricky part. It's supposed to feel hard." Children who expect struggle tend to be less alarmed by it.

Share a mistake at dinner. Once a week, everyone tells one thing that went wrong and what they tried next — parents first. It makes failure ordinary, and it's funnier than it sounds.

Keep a "not yet" list. Write down, with them, a few things they can't do yet — ride without training wheels, write their name, swim across the pool — and cross them off over the months. Seeing "not yet" turn into "done" is the growth mindset made visible.

The second thing, the one that's rarely mentioned: all of this works only if the child also has a way to get through the frustration first. Regulation comes before mindset.

What does the research really say about growth mindset?

Less than the posters on classroom walls suggest, and more than nothing.

The strongest finding is about praise. In a well-known series of experiments with 10- to 12-year-olds, children praised for being smart chose easier tasks afterward and gave up sooner than children praised for effort. That pattern has been broadly supported, though not every replication finds it as strongly.

The weaker finding is about programs. Two large meta-analyses published in 2018 — one covering 273 studies of mindset and achievement, the other 43 studies of mindset programs — found that school programs teaching growth mindset have, on average, a very small effect on achievement, with somewhat larger effects for students who were academically at risk or from low-income families. Much less of this research involves children as young as 5.

So the honest summary for parents: the way you talk about success and failure does matter, especially what you praise. But growth mindset isn't a switch, and teaching the phrase won't change much on its own. Our research brief on praise and growth mindset has the details and the sources.

Are there books that do this well for young children?

A few do it without preaching, which matters, because a story that announces its moral stops being a story.

The Most Magnificent Thing by Ashley Spires is the closest thing to a growth-mindset lesson that doesn't feel like one: the girl tries, fails, gets genuinely angry, quits, walks it off, and comes back. That full sequence — including the quitting — is what makes it useful.

Jabari Jumps by Gaia Cornwall does the same for fear rather than skill. Jabari lets other kids go ahead of him, climbs partway up, and backs down to "stretch" before he finally jumps, and the book treats the stalling as part of the process rather than a failure.

What do I say when my child says "I'm stupid"?

Don't argue with it right away. "You're not stupid, you're so clever!" is kind, but it replaces one fixed label with another, and it tells the child their feeling was wrong.

First, name the feeling underneath: "You're really frustrated. That was hard." Wait for the storm to pass — the words usually come at the peak of frustration, when nothing reasonable can be heard.

Then, calmly, separate the person from the problem: "You're not stupid. That puzzle is tricky, and you haven't figured out the corner yet." You're turning a statement about who they are into a statement about where they are on a task.

Then offer a next step, not a pep talk: "Want to try the edges first?" or "Should we come back to it after snack?" A plan usually does more than reassurance.

If "I'm stupid" comes often, across many activities, notice what you and others say about ability at home — and about yourselves. Children often pick the phrase up from adults saying "I'm hopeless at math" or "I'm so stupid" about their own small mistakes.

How do I know it's working?

Watch what they do in the ten seconds after something goes wrong, not what they say about effort.

The signs are small: they go back to a thing that beat them last week. They say "yet" without being handed it. They describe what they tried rather than whether they're good at it. They ask for the harder version.

Don't expect those in the first weeks. This is a change in what failure means to them, and meanings take months to move.

What are growth mindset strategies for kids?

Praise the process — effort, strategy, persistence — rather than being smart. Name the hard part so struggle feels normal. Add "yet" to "I can't do it" once the frustration has passed. Share your own mistakes and what you tried next. And give children plenty of tasks that are a little too hard, so there's something to grow into. These work best as everyday habits, not lessons.

Why is a growth mindset important?

Because children who see ability as something that grows are more likely to try again after failing, choose harder tasks, and recover from setbacks. The effect on school results is smaller than often claimed, but the everyday benefit is real: a child who reads failure as information rather than a verdict has a much easier time learning anything new, from reading to riding a bike.

How do children with a growth mindset see mistakes?

As information about the method, not about themselves. A child with a growth mindset thinks "that way didn't work, I'll try another way" rather than "I'm bad at this." They're more likely to go back to something that beat them and to ask for help. You can encourage this by treating your own mistakes the same way, out loud.

What are examples of growth mindset phrases for kids?

"I can't do it yet." "This is the hard part." "Let me try a different way." "Mistakes help me learn what to change." "I'm not there yet, but I'm closer." For parents: "You kept going when it got hard" and "What could you try next?" Phrases help most when they describe something the child actually did, not as slogans on a wall.

Is growth mindset just positive thinking?

No. Positive thinking says "you can do anything." A growth mindset says "you can get better at this with practice and a better method" — which is more honest and more useful. It doesn't deny that something is hard or that a child is struggling. It changes what the struggle means: not proof of a limit, but part of how skills are built.

What the research says

• Growth mindset research: what holds up about praise · Study brief
• Self talk and the "Batman effect": what happens when children look at themselves from the outside · Study brief

More to read