Raising Self talk and the "Batman effect": what happens when children look at themselves from the outside
The short version: Self talk, the way children talk to themselves, can change how they handle a hard task. In two experiments, children who pretended to be a hard-working character like Batman, or talked about themselves by name, did better: in one experiment, 5-year-olds did better on self-control tasks the more they distanced themselves, and in a second, children ages 4 and 6 who played Batman worked longest on a boring task. In the first study the effect appeared at 5 but not at 3. It all comes from a small number of lab studies.
The studies
White, R. E., & Carlson, S. M. (2016). What would Batman do? Self-distancing improves executive function in young children. Developmental Science, 19(3), 419–426. doi:10.1111/desc.12314
Who was studied: 96 children: 48 three-year-olds and 48 five-year-olds.
Design: Laboratory experiment with random assignment to four conditions: self-immersed ("I"), control, third person, and exemplar (a character like Batman)
What they found: Five-year-olds did better on executive function tasks the more distance they took from themselves, whether they thought about themselves in the third person or played a character like Batman. Three-year-olds didn't show this improvement.
White, R. E., Prager, E. O., Schaefer, C., Kross, E., Duckworth, A. L., & Carlson, S. M. (2017). The "Batman effect": Improving perseverance in young children. Child Development, 88(5), 1563–1571. doi:10.1111/cdev.12695 · free full text
Who was studied: 180 children ages 4 and 6.
Design: Laboratory experiment with random assignment
What they found: Children worked on a boring task for up to 10 minutes with an attractive video game available as a break. Children who impersonated a character like Batman worked the longest, followed by children who thought about themselves in the third person, then children who thought about themselves as "I." Six-year-olds persevered longer than 4-year-olds overall.
How strong is the evidence?
Limited. These are two experiments from one research group, with modest samples and lab tasks. We didn't find independent replications with young children. Related research with adults on distanced self-talk, using your own name or "you," points in a similar direction.
What these studies don't show
- They don't show that role-play makes children more persistent in everyday life, at school, or over time. The effect was measured during one session in a lab.
- They don't explain exactly why it works. The authors discuss alternatives, such as the role making a boring task more fun.
What it means for parents
- Before a hard task, try: "What would a brave knight do here?" or let your child pick a hard-working character to be for a few minutes.
- Invite your child to talk about themselves by name: "Is Maya working hard? What's Maya going to try next?"
- Model it out loud: "Mom is getting frustrated with this. What would Mom tell a friend to do?"
- Keep expectations realistic. It's a small tool for a moment, not a personality change.
What is self talk?
Self talk is the way we talk to ourselves, out loud or silently. Young children often do it out loud: a four-year-old building a tower might narrate, "This one goes here. No, it's too big. Try the little one."
Psychologists have long thought that this kind of private speech helps children guide their own behavior, and that it gradually turns into silent inner speech during the school years.
Self talk can also be about how you see yourself in the moment. Thinking "I'm so bad at this" feels very different from "This is hard. What could I try?" A small set of experiments has asked whether a specific kind of self talk, taking an outsider's view of yourself, helps young children keep going.
Why young children talk to themselves out loud
If you've heard a four-year-old narrate their own play, you've heard private speech: "Now the red block. Careful. Careful." It can sound like chatter, but psychologists, starting with Lev Vygotsky, have long argued that it helps children guide their own actions.
Private speech tends to increase when a task is hard, and it's thought to become quieter and more internal during the early school years, eventually turning into inner speech.
That makes the preschool years a natural time to notice and support self talk. A child who says "I can't do it!" and a child who says "This one is tricky, try again" are using the same tool in different ways. Adults can model the second kind out loud, without lecturing.
The Batman effect studies add a twist: not just what children say to themselves, but from whose point of view.
What is the Batman effect?
"The Batman effect" is the nickname for findings from Rachel White, Stephanie Carlson, and colleagues. In their studies, children were asked to think about themselves in different ways while doing a hard task.
Some thought about themselves as "I" ("Am I working hard?"). Some thought about themselves in the third person, using their own name ("Is Sam working hard?"). And some pretended to be a character known for working hard and being good at things, such as Batman.
Psychologists call this self-distancing: stepping back from your own perspective, as if looking at yourself from the outside.
What the two experiments found
In the first study, 3- and 5-year-olds did a set of executive function tasks, the kind that require stopping an automatic response or switching rules. Among 5-year-olds, performance rose along the gradient of distance, from the self-immersed condition through the control and third person to Batman, and the third-person and Batman conditions outperformed the control. Three-year-olds showed no such improvement. The authors suggest that the ability to take another's perspective, which grows a lot between 3 and 5, may be part of the reason.
In the second study, 180 children ages 4 and 6 were given a dull, repetitive computer task and asked to work on it for 10 minutes, while an exciting video game sat nearby as an optional break. Children who impersonated a character like Batman spent the most time working. Children who thought about themselves in the third person came next, and children who thought about themselves as "I" spent the least.
Six-year-olds kept working longer than 4-year-olds overall, and the authors report the same ordering of conditions across both ages.
Until there's more evidence, the safest summary is this: distanced self talk is a promising, playful tool that costs nothing to try, and it fits naturally with pretend play that children this age already love.
Why it might work, and what we don't know
One explanation is that distance helps a child see the situation more clearly and act on their goals rather than on the pull of the moment, the video game in this case. Pretending to be a hard-working character may also remind children what that character would do.
There are other possibilities. Playing a role may simply make a boring task more fun, so children stay with it longer. The authors discuss this themselves.
These were two experiments from one research group, done in a lab, with one session each. We didn't find independent replications with young children. Research with adults on using your own name or "you" in self-talk points in a similar direction, but adults and 5-year-olds are very different.
How to use self talk with your child
The cost of trying this at home is close to zero, which makes it worth a try as long as expectations stay modest.
Before something hard, like a tricky puzzle, a first swim lesson, or cleaning up a big mess, invite your child to choose a character who works hard or is brave and be that character for a few minutes. Ask what that character would do next.
Try third-person questions: "Is Leo still trying? What's Leo going to do now?" Some children find this funny, which can help too.
And try positive self talk that's concrete rather than cheerful: "This is hard. I can try one more way" is more useful than "I'm awesome." Our guide to coping skills for kids has more short phrases children can use.
If your child's inner voice is often harsh, for example "I'm stupid" or "I'm the worst," respond to the feeling first, then offer a kinder and more accurate version: "You're really frustrated. You can't do it yet, and that's okay." In Vygotsky's view, children take in the voices around them, so how adults talk about mistakes may matter.
FAQ
What is self talk?
Self talk is the way we talk to ourselves, out loud or in our heads. Young children often talk out loud while they play or work, which can help them guide what they do. Over the school years, much of it becomes silent inner speech.
What is positive self talk for kids?
Positive self talk is short, encouraging, realistic things a child can say to themselves in a hard moment, like "I can try one more time," "This is hard, and I'm still learning," or "I can do one small step." Concrete phrases are a sensible choice, though these studies didn't compare them with cheering.
How do I help my child stop negative self talk?
Listen without arguing, name the feeling, and offer a more accurate version: "You're frustrated. You can't do it yet." Model it yourself out loud. If a child talks about themselves very negatively most of the time, or seems persistently sad, talk to your pediatrician.
Does the Batman effect really work?
In two lab experiments, children ages 4 to 6 who pretended to be a hard-working character, or thought about themselves by name, did better on self-control tasks and kept working longer. It hasn't been widely replicated with young children, so treat it as a promising, low-cost idea rather than an established method.
At what age can children use third-person self talk?
In the first study, the effect appeared in 5-year-olds but not in 3-year-olds; the second study tested ages 4 and 6, possibly because taking an outside perspective develops a lot between ages 3 and 5.
The View From Above (lesson 22) is a Stoic version of the same idea: looking at a problem from a distance to see it more clearly.
Self-Control Activities for Kids: Games That Build It
Self-control activities for kids 4–7: how self-control develops, which games genuinely train it, and why instructions and reminders don't.
Read next →